Compare Car Insurance Rates in Ohio

Enter your zip code to shop for the best rates in your area:

Cheapest Car Insurance Ohio: Full and Minimum Coverage

Affiliate disclosure: Automoblog and its partners may be compensated when you purchase the products below.

  • Erie Insurance typically provides the cheapest car insurance in Ohio, with minimum-coverage rates averaging $20 per month or $240 each year.
  • Nationwide comes in with the lowest rates for full-coverage car insurance in Ohio, with prices that hover around an average of $70 per month or $840 annually.
  • Car insurance in Ohio costs an average of $34 each month for minimum auto coverage and $111 monthly for full coverage.

Compare Car Insurance Rates

Enter your zip code to shop for the best rates in your area:

On Our Partner’s Website

From our research, the cheapest auto insurance in Ohio comes from Erie Insurance at an average of $20 per month for minimum-liability coverage. Auto-Owners and Progressive also typically come with reasonable rate estimates in the Buckeye State.

Our research team looked at average car insurance rates in Ohio along with policy options, industry scores, and customer reviews to find the state’s top options. After considering the data, we picked GEICO, Erie Insurance, and Progressive as providers offering the best car insurance in Ohio.

Best Car Insurance Rates in Ohio

Average rate estimates reveal that Erie Insurance, Auto-Owners, Progressive, and Westfield give drivers the lowest average prices across the state of Ohio for minimum coverage. Since your car insurance costs could vary, it’s best to compare quotes from various providers before making a final selection.

  • Our researchers used cost data from Quadrant Information Services to find premium estimates for different types of auto insurance coverage, varying driver profiles, and some of the most populated cities in Ohio. We used this data to determine the cheapest car insurance coverage from quality providers, which you’ll find listed in tables throughout this article.
  • To determine an overall rating for each top insurance company, our team considers not only affordability but also industry standing, availability, and coverage options. We then factor in the customer experience and online reviews to establish a numerical rating out of the highest possible score of 5.0.
  • Unless stated otherwise, estimates reflect the profile of a 35-year-old driver with a clean driving record and good credit history.
Show more Show less

Ohio Car Insurance Rates at a Glance

You’ll find detailed cost estimates below, but we’ve listed out the cheapest auto insurance companies in Ohio for various driver profiles right here:

  • Cheapest full coverage: Nationwide followed by GEICO
  • Cheapest minimum coverage: Erie Insurance followed by Auto-Owners
  • Cheapest for teen drivers: Nationwide followed by Erie Insurance
  • Cheapest for drivers with a traffic violation: Erie Insurance followed by Progressive

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in Ohio

Below are our picks for the best combinations of affordable insurance with high-quality coverage for Ohio motorists. While Erie Insurance had the cheapest minimum-coverage rates in the Buckeye State, GEICO earned the top score for its flexibility and number of discounts.

Car Insurance ProviderOverall RatingAverage Monthly Rate: Minimum CoverageAverage Monthly Rate: Full CoverageNumber of Discounts
Erie Insurance4.4$20$826
State Farm4.7$61$16912

Cheapest Car Insurance Coverage in Ohio

The cheapest auto policy for Ohio drivers is state minimum-liability insurance that meets Ohio’s requirements. However, insurance experts instead recommend getting a full-coverage policy that includes bodily injury and property damage coverage for you and your vehicle.

While full coverage is more expensive, it offers far greater financial protection. If you leased your car or have an active loan on it, your leaseholder or lender may even require it.

Cheapest Minimum-Liability Car Insurance in Ohio

The average rate estimate for a minimum-coverage policy in Ohio is $34 per month or $408 per year. Erie Insurance tends to offer the cheapest minimum-liability policies with estimates of around $20 per month or $240 annually.

Car Insurance ProviderAverage Monthly Rate for Minimum CoverageAverage Yearly Rate for Minimum Coverage
Erie Insurance$20$240
Cincinnati Insurance$32$384
Grange Insurance$37$444
State Farm$61$732

Cheapest Full-Coverage Car Insurance in Ohio

In Ohio, the average rate for full-coverage auto insurance is $111 per month or $1,332 per year. Nationwide offers the cheapest average rate estimates on full-coverage insurance at $70 monthly or $840 per year.

Car Insurance ProviderAverage Monthly Rate for Full CoverageAverage Yearly Rate for Full Coverage
Erie Insurance$82$984
Grange Insurance$94$1,128
Cincinnati Insurance$125$1,500
State Farm$169$2,028

Ohio Car Insurance Quotes by Driver Profile

Your coverage rates will probably be different from the ones found in the tables above. That’s largely because car insurance companies base individual rates on multiple variables. Your age, driving record, and location all offer insight when providers set your car insurance premiums.

Six icons representing the most influential factors in the cost of car insurance premiums, including coverage choices, driving history, age, credit score, deductible, and location.

Cheapest Car Insurance in Ohio: Age

Age is easily one of the largest factors in deciding the cost of auto insurance. Young drivers and teen drivers in particular pay significantly higher rates for auto coverage than other age groups. In the table below are average monthly rate estimates for Ohio drivers of different ages:

Driver AgeAverage Monthly Rate for Minimum CoverageAverage Monthly Rate for Full Coverage

Cheapest Car Insurance in Ohio: High-Risk Drivers

Your driving history is also a key component in setting your premiums. People with clean driving records get access to cheaper car insurance rates while at-fault accidents and traffic violations such as speeding tickets usually result in higher premiums.

How much these red flags on your driving record could impact your prices varies by provider. Below are top Ohio auto insurance providers and their average minimum-coverage rates for good drivers versus high-risk drivers:

Car Insurance ProviderAverage Monthly Rate for Clean Driving RecordsAverage Monthly Rate for High-Risk Drivers
Erie Insurance$20$29
Grange Insurance$37$52
Cincinnati Insurance$32$59
State Farm$61$70

Car Insurance Rates in Ohio: Speeding Ticket

Being given a single speeding ticket can cause your auto insurance premiums to spike. Erie Insurance generally offers the cheapest car insurance for Ohio drivers with a speeding ticket with an average estimate of $22 per month or $264 per year. Auto-Owners and Westfield also offer some of the more affordable prices for this specific driver profile.

Car Insurance ProviderAverage Monthly Rate After a Speeding TicketAverage Yearly Rate After a Speeding Ticket
Erie Insurance$22$264
Cincinnati Insurance$38$456
Grange Insurance$52$624
State Farm$67$804

Car Insurance Rates in Ohio: At-Fault Accident

Ohio drivers will probably see heightened rates if they’re found at fault for a car accident. Erie Insurance tends to offer the cheapest coverage if you’ve got a recent accident with an average rate of $29 per month or $348 each year. Auto-Owners and GEICO also typically offer some of the least expensive coverage after an at-fault accident.

Car Insurance ProviderAverage Monthly Rate After an At-Fault AccidentAverage Yearly Rate After an At-Fault Accident
Erie Insurance$29$348
Grange Insurance$47$564
Cincinnati Insurance$60$720
State Farm$74$888

Car Insurance Rates in Ohio: DUI

A driving under the influence (DUI) violation usually causes Ohio auto premiums to skyrocket. For drivers with a DUI on their record, Progressive typically offers the lowest rates with an average estimate of $32 per month or $384 per year. Erie Insurance and Auto-Owners also offer some of the more affordable premiums for these drivers.

Car Insurance ProviderAverage Monthly Rate After a DUIAverage Yearly Rate After a DUI
Erie Insurance$35$420
Grange Insurance$57$684
State Farm$67$804
Cincinnati Insurance$78$936

Average Cost of Car Insurance in Ohio

The average rate for minimum-coverage car insurance in Ohio is $408 per year while it’s $1,332 each year for full coverage. Those prices are almost 35% below the national average for minimum protection and 30% cheaper than the U.S. rate for full coverage.

Average Car Insurance Cost in Ohio by City

Where you live in Ohio can have a major impact on your auto insurance premiums. Potential risk factors such as population density, crime rates, and weather patterns vary between ZIP codes and lead to varying average rates. The following table shows the average auto insurance rates for major cities across Ohio.

Cities in OhioAverage Monthly Rate for Minimum CoverageAverage Monthly Rate for Full Coverage

Ohio Minimum Car Insurance Requirements

Ohio law mandates pretty basic minimum-coverage requirements, only requiring of your policy the following coverage types and coverage limits:

  • $25,000 bodily injury liability per person
  • $50,000 bodily injury liability per accident
  • $25,000 property damage liability per accident

The majority of insurance agents and experts suggest getting policies beyond the minimum requirements set out by the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles. That’s because your own vehicle and medical bills won’t be covered if you only get what’s legally required.

Car insurance policies with collision coverage and comprehensive coverage offer protection for your own car. Injury coverage such as medical payments coverage (MedPay) can help to cover medical costs you could incur after an at-fault accident.

Additionally, uninsured motorist coverage and underinsured motorist coverage (UI/UIM) could take care of claims caused by an at-fault driver who lacks sufficient money or coverage to pay.

Is Ohio an At-Fault State?

Ohio is an at-fault state, meaning that authorities will decide which driver caused an accident. Whoever else was involved in the collision must seek damages from the driver deemed at fault.

Cheap Car Insurance in Ohio: Conclusion

The lowest price we discovered for minimum-coverage car insurance in Ohio came from Erie Insurance for $20 per month. Since rates fluctuate across the state, the best provider for a certain driver in Cincinnati might not be the same as for one in Cleveland.

It’s smart to consider a full-coverage policy, and we found rates starting at $70 each month from Nationwide. While you’ll be charged more each pay period, expect far lower bills after an at-fault accident occurs and significantly greater peace of mind.

Best Car Insurance in Ohio: Recommended Providers

By getting free quotes from multiple auto coverage providers, you’ll have a good shot at getting the cheapest car insurance in Ohio that fits your needs. We’d recommend looking at GEICO and Erie Insurance as you begin your search for the best all-around coverage in the Buckeye State.

Compare Car Insurance Rates

Enter your zip code to shop for the best rates in your area:

On Our Partner’s Website

GEICO: 4.6 out of 5.0

Ohio drivers who pick GEICO typically receive competitive rates on their insurance policies, especially if they’re considering full coverage. It’s easy to save more with the company due to its impressive range of car insurance discounts available in Ohio. The company has an A++ financial strength score from AM Best and the backing of Berkshire Hathaway, so the auto insurer will likely have no issues covering any claims you need to file.

Keep reading: GEICO insurance review

Erie Insurance: 4.4 out of 5.0

Erie Insurance is an exceptional option for Ohio motorists who plan to get a minimum-coverage policy. The company offers the lowest average rates in the state for basic liability insurance and is known to provide superb customer service. While it’s not the largest auto insurance provider, Erie Insurance is often called a strong choice by drivers who consider it.

Cheapest Auto Insurance in Ohio: FAQ

Below, you’ll find answers to some frequently asked questions about auto insurance in Ohio.

Which company gives the cheapest car insurance?

State Farm typically offers the cheapest car insurance when it comes to national average rates. In Ohio specifically, our researchers found that Erie Insurance and Auto-Owners tended to offer the lowest minimum-coverage premiums.

How much is car insurance per month in Ohio?

The average cost of car insurance per month in Ohio is $34 for a minimum-coverage policy and $111 for full coverage. Our team found rates in Ohio as low as $20 per month for minimum coverage and $70 each month for a full-coverage policy.

How to reduce car insurance in Ohio?

You can reduce the cost of car insurance in Ohio by lowering your amount and types of coverage, increasing your deductible, and applying discounts such as for homeowners who bundle policies. Over the long term, you may be able to reduce your premiums by improving your credit score and by staying accident-free. Another method is to look for lower rates as you compare auto insurance quotes.

How much is car insurance on average in Ohio?

On average, car insurance in Ohio costs around $408 per year for a minimum-coverage policy. The average cost of a full-coverage car insurance policy in Ohio is around $1,332 annually.

Is it illegal to drive without insurance in Ohio?

It is illegal to drive without car insurance in Ohio. You can be charged with a misdemeanor criminal offense for driving without auto insurance and could face possible penalties such as fines, loss of driving privileges, and brief jail time.

Is it cheaper to pay car insurance every six months or monthly?

It’s almost always cheaper to pay for car insurance every six months than it is to pay monthly. This is because many companies offer a discount for paying for your policy upfront rather than over monthly payments. Not every auto insurer actually offers this discount, though.

Our Methodology

Our expert review team takes satisfaction in providing accurate and unbiased information. We identified the following rating categories based on consumer survey data and conducted extensive research to formulate rankings of the best car insurance providers.

  • Affordability: A variety of factors influence cost, so it can be difficult to compare quotes between providers. Our team considers auto insurance rate estimates generated by Quadrant Information Services and discount opportunities when giving this score.
  • Coverage: Because each consumer has unique needs, it’s essential that a car insurance company offers an array of coverage options. We take into account types of insurance available, maximum coverage limits, and add-on policies.
  • Industry Standing: Our team considers Better Business Bureau (BBB) ratings, financial strength, and years in business when giving this score.
  • Availability: Auto insurers with greater state availability and few eligibility requirements are more likely to meet consumer needs.
  • Customer Service: Reputable car insurance providers operate with a certain degree of care for consumers. We consider complaints filed with the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), J.D. Power claims servicing scores, and customer feedback.
  • Online Experience: Insurers with easy-to-use websites and highly rated mobile apps scored best in this category.

*Data accurate at time of publication.