Buyer's guide to used car warranties

Autopom! vs. CarShield Extended Warranty Comparison

  • We compare autopom! vs. CarShield to help you decide which provider best fits your needs.
  • Autopom! and CarShield received the same overall rating from our review team. Autopom! scored higher on industry standing and customer service, while CarShield scored higher on coverage and affordability.
  • Our highest-rated warranty providers are Endurance and CARCHEX. You can read more about them in our comprehensive review of the best extended warranty companies.

Affiliate disclosure: Automoblog and its partners may be compensated when you purchase the products below.

Trying to compare extended warranties from autopom! vs. CarShield? We’ve done the homework for you.

In this side-by-side comparison, we’ll examine both providers’ coverage plan options, costs, customer reviews, and more to help you decide which auto protection company will give you better peace of mind.

To start comparing autopom! vs. CarShield prices for your vehicle, you can get a free, personalized quote from each company below.

Top Extended Warranty Companies
We reviewed the best extended auto warranty providers, and here are our top picks. 
Best Customer Service Best Prices
autopom logo logo carshield
Autopom! CarShield
black starblack starblack starblack starblack half star 5 1 black starblack starblack starblack starblack half star 5 1
Get Quote Get Quote
(888) 691-2354 (800) 563-2761
   

Overview of autopom! vs. CarShield

Both autopom! and CarShield ranked high on our list of the best extended warranty providers, but how do the two companies compare? Here’s a breakdown of how we scored autopom! vs. CarShield:

  autopom! CarShield
Industry Standing 4.5 4.0
Coverage 4.0 5.0
Affordability 4.0 5.0
Customer Reviews 4.5 4.0
Overall Rating 4.5 4.5

Autopom! and CarShield are both major players in the extended warranty industry. CarShield was founded in 2005 and is arguably the industry’s most popular provider, with thousands of online reviews, celebrity endorsements, and over $1 billion paid in claims by CarShield’s administrators. Autopom! was founded in 2009 and has differentiated itself by working exclusively with A-rated administrators and insurers and covering vehicles up to 14 years old.

Although there are more CarShield reviews overall, autopom! reviews are a bit more positive. The company holds a higher average customer review rating on both its Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot profiles. Autopom! also holds BBB accreditation, while CarShield does not. Although autopom! has advantages in industry standing and reviews, CarShield offers superior coverage and is generally more affordable.

Autopom! vs. CarShield: Coverage

Autopom! and CarShield each offer a number of different coverage options to choose from that can cover new and high-mileage vehicles.

  autopom! CarShield
Coverage Rating 4.0 5.0
Coverage Levels 4 6
Highest Mileage Limit 150,000 miles 200,000 miles
Waiting Period for Coverage 30 days and 1,000 miles 30 days and 1,000 miles
Sample Contracts Available Yes Yes

Both providers have plans ranging from basic powertrain coverage for just the engine, transmission, and drivetrain to full bumper-to-bumper warranties that cover repairs for all major systems, including the air conditioning, suspension, and electrical components.

However, CarShield offers two more levels of coverage than autopom!, including a plan specifically for motorcycles and all-terrain vehicles and a plan designed for luxury vehicles or vehicles with complex electronic systems. The high-tech plan covers cruise control, power seat control, voice activation control, and more.

Autopom! and CarShield both offer additional benefits including roadside assistance, towing, and rental car reimbursement, but autopom! gives customers trip interruption coverage and tire protection services too.

Autopom! vs. CarShield: Cost

When it comes to cost, autopom! and CarShield are both affordable choices for an extended car warranty. We found CarShield to have slightly lower monthly payments and total prices than autopom!.

Factors such as the plan you select and your vehicle’s mileage, model, and age affect the cost of an extended warranty plan. We reached out to both providers for a quote on a 2018 Toyota Camry with 28,000 miles. Here’s a side-by-side comparison of autopom! vs. CarShield prices:

  autopom! CarShield
Plan Exclusionary New Car Diamond
Term Length 5 years/51,000 miles 5 years/100,000 miles
Price $1,830.00 upfront $83.28 per month for 18 months
Down Payment None $295.00
Total Price $1,830.00 $1,794.04
Price Per Year of Coverage $366.00 $358.81
Deductible $100.00 $100.00

As you can see, autopom! and CarShield offer similar total costs for coverage. However, we rated CarShield higher for affordability because of its longer term length and low monthly payments. Additionally, in this example, autopom! only provided us with an upfront price rather than a financing option. This is not always the case with autopom!, but it made the decision easy for the budget-conscious shopper.

Autopom! vs. CarShield: Customer Reviews & Reputation

Hundreds of customer reviews have been submitted for autopom! and CarShield via the BBB and Trustpliot. Additionally, the BBB itself takes into account business practices and handling of complaints when determining its scores.

  autopom! CarShield
BBB Accreditation Yes No
BBB Rating A+ F
BBB Customer Rating 4.5 out of 5.0 stars with 25 reviews 2.5 out of 5.0 stars with 569 reviews
Number of BBB Complaints in the Last Three Years 1 868
Trustpilot Rating 4.7 out of 5.0 stars with ?81 reviews 4.2 out of 5.0 stars with ?10,456 reviews

 *Data accurate at time of publication.

Overall, customers have mostly positive experiences with both brands. Autopom! has an edge over CarShield in every category, but its customer ratings are based on significantly fewer reviews. Far more reviews of CarShield were submitted on Trustpilot than the BBB, so the company’s 4.2-star Trustpilot score is probably more indicative of customers’ overall experience than its 2.5-star rating on the BBB.

CarShield received an F rating from the BBB due to advertising issues and having hundreds of complaints filed against the business. While this is indeed a large number of complaints, it’s important to consider that CarShield has hundreds of thousands of customers. Still, some customers may reasonably prefer autopom! because of its A+ BBB rating and accreditation.

To get a feel for customers’ experiences with these companies, we read a number of reviews for each provider. Below, we share a sample positive and negative review for autopom! vs. CarShield. Generally, customers appreciate autopom! and CarShield’s coverage and affordable costs, but some customers felt that their claims were denied for unjustified reasons.

Positive Reviews:

autopom!

“[My service representative] was timely in getting my questions answered. He had a pleasant and respectful demeanor about him and represented autopom! in an excellent and professional manner.” – M.D. Cathcart via Trustpilot

CarShield

“CarShield has been a great investment. I have two vehicles, and they both have CarShield. They have good customer service and the team [works with you] to get your issue solved. I have recommended CarShield to several of my friends and coworkers.” – Janice Anderson via Trustpilot

Negative Reviews:

autopom!

“My complaint is against the administrator, not autopom! However, an insurance policy is only a promise, and only as good as the claims handling and payment process. This company’s administrator is worthless and refuses to pay claims…” – R.B. F. via BBB

CarShield

“So far, our experience with CarShield has been questionable at [best]. Everything is great as long as they are taking your premiums. As soon as you make a claim, the nightmare begins. Their claims department is impossible to get a hold of.” – Jill K. via BBB

Final Thoughts on autopom! vs. CarShield

Autopom! and CarShield are reputable extended car warranty companies that offer comprehensive coverage and standard benefits at a competitive price. What’s best for one driver may not be best for another, so we recommend getting quotes from both companies to find the right fit for your vehicle.

  autopom! CarShield
Coverage Levels 4 6
Sample Contracts Available Yes Yes
Deductible Varies Varies
Years in Business 10 15
Accepted Repair Sites Any licensed repair shop Any licensed repair shop
Transferable Plan Yes Yes
Cancellable Plan Yes Yes
30-Day Money-Back Guarantee Yes Yes
Endorsements None Chris Berman, Ice-T, Ernie Hudson, and Andrienne Janic
Get Free Quote Get Quote Get Quote

Other Recommendations for Extended Car Warranties

When looking for an extended warranty provider, it’s wise to compare coverage plans and costs from multiple top companies. Along with autopom! and CarShield, we recommend getting quotes from Endurance and CARCHEX.

Endurance: Best Direct Coverage

Our No. 1 recommended provider, Endurance offers five outstanding coverage plans, strong customer service, and a unique benefits package. In addition to all of the standard benefits such as roadside assistance and towing, Endurance’s vehicle service contracts come with two tire replacements or repairs per year, ID theft protection, key fob replacement, concierge service, and a $250 retail voucher. 

You can learn more in our complete Endurance warranty review and get a free quote using the buttons below.

Best Direct Coverage

black starblack starblack starblack starblack star

logo endurance

Get Quote

(877) 374-1840

Industry veteran that handles your plan directly, from quote to claim

CARCHEX: Best for Older Vehicles

CARCHEX is an eight-time Inc. 5000 honoree and holds significant sponsorships with CARFAX, Edmunds.com, and Kelley Blue Book. We recognized CARCHEX as the Best for Older Vehicles because it covers cars up to 250,000 miles. What’s more, CARCHEX holds an A+ rating from the BBB and offers five different coverage levels.

Read our in-depth CARCHEX review to learn more about this provider and get a custom quote for your vehicle below.

Best for Older Vehicles

black starblack starblack starblack starblack star

logo

Get Quote

(866) 254-0205

Top-rated provider with unmatched customer service and affordable coverage

How to Get Invoice Pricing



.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read This Next
Nissan Pathfinder Rock Creek 15
Plymouth Rock Car Insurance Reviews and Our Take (2020)