Should Old People be Banned from Driving? - revisit

Back when I first started AutomoBlog in May of last year, I wrote a post about the elderly and what restrictions should be placed on them regarding driving. Clearly this is an issue on the roads, and people had many opinions to share regarding the issue. I would like to revisit the post, and hear some more opinions regarding the matter.

In the time since that post was written, I’ve personally experienced more bad situations regarding the issue, and I’m sure many of my readers have as well.

Should elderly drivers be banned from driving? Many seem to think so. Motorinsurance.co.uk, an online insurance broker reported that 49% of drivers want elderly drivers banned. Paul Cosh is the managing director of MotorInsurance, and had a few comments on which I would like to comment:

“I do not think that picking on this nation’s most careful and experienced drivers is really the answer.

Yeah, my dad was awesome at football back in his day. He’s very experienced, that doesn’t mean he should still do it.

“To be honest, the views shown by this poll are quite shocking and simply do not stand up against the facts.

“Of course increased age brings its challenges, but healthy older drivers typically try to compensate for deficiencies. If anything, they also drive more carefully and avoiding risk-taking in general.

“To suggest that older drivers are a danger on the roads is a statistically unfounded stereotype and if anyone wants to debate the safety record of an 80 year-old compared with the average 20 year-old, my door is always open.”

The point is, I know for a fact that old people are a danger on the roads. I have seen many accidents (some involving people I know) that were caused by nothing but an incompetent old person not paying attention, and not having the reaction times necessary to avoid a potentially dangerous situation, making it worse.

Paul Cosh, who I quoted above is clearly an idiot, but banning old people from driving completely seems a little bit extreme. But what about people who can’t react in a timely manner, can’t make reasonable decisions, and can’t see or hear as well as other drivers? Allowing them on the road as freely as anybody else is as ridiculous as allowing drunk drivers on the road. I’ve been in one accident and have otherwise had very close situations in which I had to make fast decisions as to what to do, and only one has been from a drunk driver. The others from old people who didn’t know what they were doing, and I would be surprised if they knew where they were. Disclaimer: I do not have anything against old people, and I hate drunk drivers. I don’t want you to take the last paragraph the wrong way. I just have a problem with old people driving.

So back to the solution. What to do? Like I said above, banning them all from the road completely is extreme, but allowing them all to drive is ridiculous. I propose that beginning at age 65 (maybe 70,) the driver takes a strict driving test every year. Obviously this will keep the dangerous ones off the road, and the competent ones can still drive. A few states already implement something like this, like Rhode Island who requires drivers over 70 to renew their licenses every two years but take only the standard vision test. However, I think it should be more thorough. Illinois requires road tests for drivers over 75 who want to renew their licenses, while 15 other states have an accelerated renewal schedule. At least five states have stopped mail-in renewals for older drivers. But that’s obviously not enough.

What are your opinions on this? Do you think all people over a certain age should be banned, or do you think everybody should have the right to drive? What age should we start requiring testing, and how frequent should the testing be?

[…] Over at Automoblog, Egon is celebrating his first anniversary. To acknowledge the occasion he is revisiting a controversial topic that was posted early on. Should oldsters be banned from roaming our highways? […]

[…] Over at Automoblog, Egon is celebrating his first anniversary. To acknowledge the occasion he is revisiting a controversial topic that was posted early on. Should oldsters be banned from roaming our highways? […]

So here’s my two cents… *steps up on soap box*

Senior citizens are deserving of the road just as much as you or I. But just as I believe every teenager should go through driving tests (not this randomly selected by birthmonth BS) I believe that senior citizens should be subject to them.

The eye-sight test at the DMV is not enough… and just because a senior, highschooler, middle aged man, etc etc can pass that test does NOT mean that they are fit for the road.

I do believe that it is an issue that seniors should be tested; because theres a good ammount of them out there that do require testing in their driving skills. But just as I believe any one should have to do a driving test every two years or so, seniors should be subject to that.

Lets face it, health degrades; unfortunately… and as health degrades, so does certain skills previously talked about. But that does not mean that every senior should be off of the road. Those who deserve to be off the road should be off the road. Test driving skills every two years on EVERYONE, including seniors, and if the driver fails for what ever reason, be it age or being an idiot, they don’t deserve to share the road with me outside of public transportation.

*steps off of soapbox*

There ya go guys.

I agree in part. Driving test yes, every two years? I don’t think so. I would say 5 is a more reasonable number. Let’s not trade one problem for another. Dare I say it? Yes I must, the line at the DMV would be unbearable (even more so than the extent it already is).

My main problem with seniors driving is their speed and slow turns. I don’t really have a suggestion for a solution on the slow turns, but let’s add a minimum speed limit to more area’s. 10 below the speed limit sounds fine to me. You go 11 under and get a ticket.

I always like to look on both sides of the coin so…. They have been paying taxes longer than we have so they own more road than I do. Most would probably get a better score on a driving test than I would, but be done an hour after me. It is a tough toss-up.

*Congrats egon on the first anniversary*

John & Fidelus: I agree with both of you, and Fidelus has a good point that 2 years might be too frequent, only because that would create more problem at the DMV.

I also agree that there should be a minimum speed limit, although I think it should be more like 5mph; going too slow on the road creates a serious hazard, especially in high-traffic areas.

i hate old drivers they should all go and die!!!!!!

Andrew, that’s a bit extreme, isn’t it?

eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

hey andrew i am 94 years old and i still drive so you go and die

THAT DICK HOLE IS STILL DRIVIN AT 94 SOUNDS LIKE HE NEEDS TO DIE

first of all no NINETY FOUR YEAR OLD would leave a comment that immature on a website like this. so all of you should feel pretty dumb, haha way to go dumbass’ ! secondly, i do agree that if an elderly person is not able to make quick decisions as supposed to then they shouldnt be driving

Old people need to be kicked off the road immediately.

This is to Egon and Fidelus. You both are looking at the wrong issues here…
1st: every two years is not extreme at all, I would rather stand in a line a few minutes longer if it meant safer drivers on the road. AND do you realize how much impact 2 years can have on an older person? A lot can change in those two years, especially if they have Alzheimers.
2nd: the fact that older people drive slow is not the main safety issue, I’m not saying it’s not a safety issue, I am just saying it’s not the main one. And fyi policemen DO give out tickets for driving too slow. Research first, THAN act like you know what you’re talking about. But anyways the main issues with older drivers are when they switch lanes with no warning, and when they stop suddenly when driving in front of you, or when they react too late and rear end you.

Jo, I don’t understand your comment. You said I’m looking at the wrong issues, yet you just reinforced my points…

im 14 and i went out with someone who was 74 she was a great driver. Oh the good days in mcdonalds and our long talks in the car

Our “senior citizens” need to be more careful when they drive!

Hey Jo. Maybe you should learn some grammar before you go tearing other comments down. “Research first, THAN act like you know what you’re talking about.” It’s “then” not “than.” And I believe what the “main” issue is the deterioration of driving skills that tends to occur with older drivers. You are simply naming situations that older drivers have issues coping with due to their depleted skill level. There are also several other arguments that are for a necessary age-based assessment of older drivers. For one, older people are much more fragile than younger drivers. Statistically, older drivers (65+) are only the second most likely to get in a car accident (Of course, first place belongs to drivers aged 16-20). Even given that young drivers are more likely to get into a wreck, older drivers are the most likely to get in a fatal accident. These facts are certainly more important than older drivers simply being an annoyance on the road, and I assure you there are many more reasons. And no, I’m not simply pulling these statistics out of thin air. There are several scholarly journals on this exact subject, and I’ve read many of these since I’ve already written a paper arguing for the retesting of older drivers. Good day.

Old people should be made to modify their cars so that under a certain speed there is an audible/visible alarm!
J/K..
Seriously, however, I do believe that there are many risks involved with letting elderly drivers on the road. I agree with Amber in that older drivers are an “annoyance” on the road, but think about it in more detail. The main reason I sometimes drive agressively is because of these annoyances. Elimate them and it’s not too far in the realm of impossibility that drivers could be a lot calmer. Road and vision tests only do one thing: give the government more money. There has to be more for the amount of money that is spent: hand-eye coordination, reaction time, quick decisioning, etc. These are things that we “young” people take for granted, yet they deteriorate as we age. I believe there should be a certain cut-off for these tests, and if you fail, you don’t get to drive. Driving shouldn’t just be about how one takes a corner, shoulder checks before turning or comes to a complete stop at a stop sign, they should really incorporate other tests to determine driver competency.

Oh, and if you are a senior, pull over to the damned side of the road if you have a queue of cars behind you!

P.S. - egon - you can run faster than 5 mph.
P.P.S - Maybe the slow alarm wouldn’t be such a bad idea!

Sean: I meant it should be 5mph under the speed limit, not 5mph total. (This is egon)

Oh, right on. I wrote a hurried post last time and didn’t take the time to read all the posts!

This is a very interesting subject. Instead of emotional pleas from everyone I think that we need to do some statistical analysis based on information collected regarding accidents among people of different ages. I do think that as we get older we should be tested on the road more frequently and using the same test you have to pass in order to get a driver license when you are a kid.

I don’t think that its desirable or practical to ban “old people” from the road. In fact, we could learn a thing or two about driving from them at times. Yes, some elderly people drive too slow. Most simply drive the speed limit and obey the traffic laws so as to make for a safe driving experience for themselves and everyone else sharing the road with them.

We should all follow that example anyway.

Have a nice day.

Don’t forget that driving the speed limit and driving carefully not only saves lives but also reduces greenhouse gas emissions and saves gas as well. Less gas burned saves you money and also reduces our dependence on foreign oil. Have a nice day.

You’re right John, I think tests need to be done and the law should be based on something much more specific than “ban old people.” I also agree that we can be too aggressive as a whole while driving. However, no matter how much we *should* be driving more conservatively, we don’t. And that means that driving too slow and too conservatively is a hazard. Should it be? No, but it is, regardless of how it *should* be.

My main problem with “old people” driving is that many of them don’t have the ability, reflexes, vision, and hearing to drive safely, but they do anyway. In fact I was standing in a parking lot two days ago smoking, and witnessed a man (he must have been at least 80 years old) back right into a parked Buick. There were no cars around, he had plenty of room, yet he backed right up into it, causing damage. When he got out he could barely walk. He should not have been on the road. He poses a serious danger to other drivers, and should have his license revoked. Yet we still allow this…why?

I am 15 years old and next week I will be taking the driving test to obtain my license. From what I’ve learned in driver’s ed. and experience on the road, the most problematic areas are in high traffic. It’s not just older people but people of all ages. My dad, who is 37, is a worse driver than all of my grandparents. I think that this is caused from a lapse in teaching young drivers. If you never learn to drive right in the first place it’s going to show on the road. I think that we should implement a test starting at the age of 65 that would require a little more depth than the standard driver’s test. It is, however, a fact that older people are a danger on the road. In fact they almost tie my age group in probability of wrecking.

You’re right Mitch, it seems to me that driving skill is slowly going out the door as years go on. I don’t know how to fix it, but something needs to change, people are just becoming too selfish to care about using blinkers, being courteous, staying in the right lane unless passing, etc. It’s becoming ridiculous just to drive anymore.

Old people rule!

We Are Doing Science Corsework at my school and the quiestion
is ‘Should old people be aloud to drive?’
id like it if any people would be able to help me by givng me websites to check out
or leave a comment about what you think.
Thanks x

Emma, We r also doin coursework and u don’t hear us askin 4 help, do your own work, spooner

Well Emma, you see all of our opinions in the article or in the comments. If you need clarification, just ask.

Smokin’ hot chick .. right coz i do know ya !
i dont come onto decent sites to start a shit stir so dont be a
” spooner ” as you say and sort ya life out !
and don’t bother writing bak i dont really talk to low lifes that go onto sites like this just to start shit !!

Its very simple, after a certain age give them a driving test and if they can still drive let them drive, if not then ban them from driving.

I agree with Daine. As people grow older, they should take tests more and more frequently. Tests that will evaluate their competence to drive safely.

hello io think old people should be banned from driving because my cousin died by one

OLD PEOPLE SHOULD NOT DRIVE>>IVE SEEN SO MANY OLD PEOPLE WHO CAN BARELY SEE OVER THE STEARING WHEEL AND THEY CANT SEE THE ROAD AND RUN RED LIGHTS SWITCH LANES WITHOUT LOOKING THEY SHOULD BE BANNED OR RETESTED OVER 65 END OF STORY NO QUESTIONS ASKED! I SAW AN OLD MAN HIT MY CAR RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME WHILE IT WAS PARKED NOT TO MENTION THE COUNTLESS TIMES IM DRIVING AND THEY ALMOST HIT ME ON THE ROAD. WATCH THE SOUTH PARK EPISODE WITH OLD PEOPLE DRIVING IT ACTUALLY HAS A GOOD POINT!

Thhe old man is the picture looks sexy

listen here all you old people. I’m still alive. I like to eat old people. they are chewy. easy to brake their bones.
keep driving chuck…
Im already after you!

wassup bitches and hoes hows it hanging ? lots of love todger

Old People Are Mighty Sexy I Love Them
Keep Them On The Road Ya’ll Peace!